Why choosing the cheapest quote is not enough
In many organizations, comparing quotes ends with one question: which is cheapest? It looks disciplined, but it ignores what happens after signing: late delivery that stops work, a lower-quality item replaced months later, or a supplier who does not honour payment terms. A low price that costs more later is not a saving.
An evaluation matrix solves this. It turns a personal impression into a documented decision that any manager or auditor can follow.
Step 1: Set the criteria before opening the quotes
The most common mistake is defining criteria after seeing the offers, which unintentionally shapes them around one supplier. Write the criteria and their weights into the request for quotation itself, and send them to every supplier.
Common criteria:
- Total price (including transport, taxes and installation)
- Compliance with technical specifications
- Delivery time
- Warranty and after-sales service
- Payment terms
- The supplier's track record with similar items
Step 2: Give each criterion a clear weight
Not every criterion matters equally. For a standard item such as stationery, price may be 70% of the score. For technical equipment or systems, price may be equal to quality, or less.
A balanced example:
- Price: 40%
- Technical compliance: 30%
- Delivery time: 15%
- Warranty and service: 15%
The weights must add up to 100% and be fixed before quotes arrive.
Step 3: Separate technical and financial evaluation
Good practice is to assess technical compliance first, without looking at prices. A non-compliant offer is excluded however low its price. Only then are the financial offers of qualified bidders opened.
This separation protects the decision from bias and answers the auditor's first question in advance.
Step 4: Convert price into a score consistently
The simplest common method: the lowest price gets full marks, and every other offer gets a score in proportion to the lowest price divided by its own.
Example with a 40-point price weight:
- Offer A: 10,000 → 40 points
- Offer B: 12,500 → (10,000 ÷ 12,500) × 40 = 32 points
- Offer C: 11,000 → (10,000 ÷ 11,000) × 40 = 36.4 points
Step 5: Score the other criteria on one scale
Use a single scale, for example 1 to 5, with a written definition for each score. For delivery time: 5 = within a week, 3 = within two weeks, 1 = more than a month. Written definitions keep committee members consistent.
Step 6: Make it a committee decision, not one person's
One person should not evaluate and decide alone. Use a committee of at least three; each member scores independently, the average is taken, and each signs a conflict-of-interest declaration.
Step 7: Record the decision in one report
The final report brings together: quotes received, technical results, final scores, the winning offer and the reason for selection. If the highest-scoring bidder does not win for any reason, the reason must be written down.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Comparing prices on unequal terms, such as one offer including transport and another not
- Changing the weights after opening the quotes
- Accepting a single quote where competition is required, without documenting why
- Keeping a table with no signatures or date
Conclusion
An evaluation matrix is not meant to add bureaucracy. It makes every purchasing decision clear and defensible, to management, to the auditor, and to the supplier who did not win.
We have prepared a ready-to-use Excel template with the request for quotation and an evaluation matrix that calculates technical and financial scores automatically. Download it free from the Templates & Tools section: orgexa.com/en/r/rfq-template